
Apple released iTunes 8 to the public on Tuesday. As a major iTunes user, I was more curious about this than the new iPods, the details of which we have known for a while. While iTunes 8 is certainly not a major update, there are some interesting new features.
First of all, the much-touted Genius functionality. Genius is a feature that analyzes your iTunes library and the uploads that information into a shared repository maintained by Apple. The information is supposedly anonymous, etc, but we’re talking music genres, artists, ratings and play count information, so I’m not all the concerned either way. Anyways, once enabled, it allows you to select a track and generate a playlist based on that particular song. I have created several “Genius Playlists” and with the exception of an odd track or two, it has worked remarkably well and has created some very enjoyable playlists. The other aspect is that it can recommend songs to you based on songs in your library. These songs can then be purchased from the iTunes Store. I may use it to discover new music, but I don’t typically buy from iTunes. I despise restrictive DRM and even their non-DRM’ed tracks are in Apple’s m4a format. I buy my digital music from Amazon’s excellent MP3 service.
There is one major problem with Genius right now though: The Beatles. Well, not exclusively The Beatles, but they are the most glaring example. The Genius feature apparently employs some data from the iTunes store, even when simply creating playlists from your own library. As such, artists that are not present in the iTunes Store do not work with the Genius feature. For example, I can not use the song Hey Jude as a source for a Genius playlist because The Beatles are not available from the iTunes Store. This is true for other artists as well. This is poor design and Apple should address it. The Genius feature should be “genius” enough to build playlists based on artists not on the iTunes Store using data from my own library and that of the libraries of others out in “the cloud.” A big thumbs down for this glaring omission. Genius is a great feature overall, but Apple needs to fix it.
Apple has also added a new Grid View for viewing your library by album cover. This is a nice looking view, but it is something other players have had for a while and is a feature I’ll rarely use. Still, it does look very pretty. Check it out here.
iTunes has a new, “improved” visualization now. While it is certainly interesting-looking, visualizations never interested me much back in 1998 with Winamp and not much has changed. I guess it could look cool on a big screen TV or something at a party, but I really don’t care much for visualizations and I can’t imagine too many other people care either.
Another welcome addition to iTunes 8 is the ability to set much more specific preferences for podcast downloads. Bravo! It’s about time!
iTunes is a large, cumbersome, resource-intensive application, but the actual resource utilization in this version does not seem to have increased, which is a good thing. In addition, the application itself seems a good bit more responsive. Moving around within it seems to be much smoother, with fewer pauses or hesitations. Many people complain about the impact iTunes has on a system. It is certainly not lightweight. However, for managing my music library (which is hundreds of GB), iTunes does exactly what I need and want it to do and I don’t plan to replace it anytime soon (though I am keeping a sharp eye on Songbird).
Generally speaking, iTunes 8 is a worthy upgrade. The Genius feature is something I’ll use (but they need to correct its glaring flaw), podcast configuration is much improved and resource impact is about the same. If you are a heavy iTunes user, I’d recommend this latest version.
Tags: Apple, genius, genius bar, genius playlists, itunes, itunes 8